Public Hospital KPIs Compared: Japan vs UK
Basic Facts: A Tale of Two Systems
Both Japan and the UK operate large public hospital systems under heavy demand. But their key performance indicators show significant divergence in recent years.
| KPI | UK (public hospitals) | Japan (public hospitals) |
|---|---|---|
| Waiting list / treatment backlog | Around 7.4 million patients on waiting list in England as of Aug 2025. House of Commons Library+2Nuffield Trust+2 | Not directly comparable waiting-list figure found, but Japan reports average length of stay for general beds of 15.7 days (2023) Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare+2Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare+2 |
| Average length of stay (general beds) | Data not clearly found for recent national average in UK public hospitals in this summary | 15.7 days for “General beds” in hospitals in Japan in 2023 Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare |
| Bed occupancy / bed availability | UK hospitals under pressure: A&E waits—about 25% of patients waiting more than 4 hours in A&E (Sep 2025) Nuffield Trust+1 | Japan has bed-beds per 1,000 population at 12.6 (higher than OECD average) OECD |
| Implementation of clinical indicators / performance measurement | UK has broad performance dashboards via NHS Digital & others. UHS+1 | In 2024 survey ~58.5% of public hospitals in Japan reported using clinical indicators; large hospitals ~88.1%. ResearchGate+1 |
Why the UK is Losing Ground: Strategy, Culture & Systemic Constraints
The UK faces very long waiting lists, rising backlog. The standard that 92% of patients should start elective treatment within 18 weeks has not been met for years. The King's Fund+2House of Commons Library+2
Infrastructure and capacity pressures: high bed occupancy, large number of patients waiting for admission or waiting over 4 hours in A&E.
Japan benefits from a higher hospital-bed density, shorter average stays, more systematic measurement of clinical indicators and strong operational discipline.
Cultural and organisational factors: Japan’s health system emphasises structure, efficiency, and institutional processes, while in the UK the system is under significant financial and workforce stress, plus constraints on scaling capacity quickly.
Lessons for the UK
Improve capacity and infrastructure (beds, staff, facilities) so that waiting lists and delays reduce.
Shorten average length of stay and improve patient flow so resources are freed up more quickly.
Expand and rigorously use clinical & operational KPIs across all hospitals, not just large ones, to monitor performance and drive improvement.
Cultivate a systemic culture of continuous improvement, operational discipline, and resource optimisation.
發表文章
