Shared Resources, Individual Greed: Dr. Yung-mei Tsai and the Tragedy of the Commons
Imagine a beautiful community garden. If everyone picks only what they need, the garden flourishes. But if one person decides to take extra to sell, and then others follow suit to avoid "missing out," the garden is picked bare in days. This is the Tragedy of the Commons, a social and economic trap that defines many of our modern crises.
Meet Dr. Yung-mei Tsai
To help students and the public understand this complex human behavior, Dr. Yung-mei Tsai, a distinguished Professor of Sociology at Texas Tech University, published a landmark paper in 1993. Dr. Tsai was an expert in urban sociology and social psychology, dedicated to revealing how social structures influence individual choices. His work turned abstract theories into lived experiences, most notably through his classroom simulation models.
What is the "Tragedy of the Commons"?
First coined by Garrett Hardin, the theory suggests that individuals acting independently and rationally according to their own self-interest will eventually deplete a shared resource, even when it is clear that it is not in anyone's long-term interest for this to happen.
Daily Examples of the Tragedy:
The Office Fridge: Everyone uses it, but no one cleans it. Eventually, it becomes a biohazard because everyone assumes "someone else" will take care of it while they continue to store their own food.
Public Wi-Fi: When everyone at a cafe starts streaming 4K video simultaneously, the "common" bandwidth crashes, and no one can even send a simple email.
Traffic Congestion: Every driver chooses the "fastest" route on GPS. When everyone makes the same selfish choice, that road becomes a parking lot.
Overfishing: If one boat catches more fish to increase profit, others do the same to compete. Soon, the fish population collapses, and all fishermen lose their livelihoods.
The Game: Dr. Tsai’s Classroom Simulation
Dr. Tsai’s 1993 simulation provides a powerful "aha!" moment for participants. Here is how it is played:
The Setup:
The Pool: A bowl in the center of a group (4-5 people) filled with 16 "resources" (candies, crackers, or tokens).
The Goal: Collect as many tokens as possible.
The Rounds: Each round, players can take 0, 1, 2, or 3 tokens.
The Regeneration: This is the key. At the end of each round, the instructor doubles whatever is left in the bowl (up to the original capacity of 16).
The Typical Outcome:
Phase 1 (No Communication): Players usually grab 3 tokens immediately, fearing others will take them all. The bowl is empty by the end of round one. The resource is dead. No regeneration occurs. Everyone "loses" the potential for a long-term supply.
Phase 2 (Communication Allowed): Players talk and realize that if everyone only takes 1 token, the bowl stays healthy, doubles every round, and everyone can eat forever.
The Lesson: Dr. Tsai showed that without communication or shared rules, individual rationality leads to collective ruin.Cooperation isn't just "nice"—it's a survival strategy.
發表文章
