The Intellectual Proletariat: From Late Ming Tutors to the AI Era

 

The Intellectual Proletariat: From Late Ming Tutors to the AI Era

In the Late Ming Dynasty, a growing class of scholar-officials found themselves in a state of professional precariousness. Often failing to secure government positions, they turned to "private tutoring" (shushi) as a means of survival. This existence was defined by "finding a post" (miguan), a process reliant on fragile social credit and short-term contracts that rarely exceeded a single year. For these men, teaching was not a realization of their lofty Confucian ideals but a desperate strategy for "supporting one's studies through teaching" (jiduzisheng).

Today’s PhD graduates face a strikingly similar landscape. Much like the late Ming tutors, modern doctoral holders often find themselves in an "academic gig economy," moving between short-term post-doctoral fellowships and adjunct positions with little hope of tenure. The social credit once required to find a post has been replaced by hyper-competitive grant applications and publication metrics, yet the fundamental instability remains.

However, a new set of pressures complicates the modern intellectual's plight. While Ming tutors struggled with an oversupply of scholars, today’s educators face a shrinking demand due to plummeting birthrates in Western nations. With fewer students entering the pipeline, the traditional institutional roles for high-level intellectuals are evaporating. Simultaneously, the rise of Artificial Intelligence and advanced self-learning platforms is challenging the very necessity of a human mentor. Just as the late Ming tutor was forced to "flatter the student and the parent" to secure a post, modern academics find themselves competing not just with each other, but with algorithms that offer personalized, immediate, and infinitely scalable knowledge. The "Way of the Teacher" (shidao), already perceived to be in decline during the Ming, now faces a structural obsolescence in a world where the seeker of knowledge can bypass the master entirely

The Wandering Mentors: The Precarious Life of Private Tutors in the Late Ming

 

The Wandering Mentors: The Precarious Life of Private Tutors in the Late Ming

The Late Ming Dynasty was a period of intense social and economic flux, a reality reflected poignantly in the lives of private tutors, known as shushi. These educators, often unsuccessful candidates in the imperial examinations, navigated a professional landscape defined by "覓館" (miguan—the search for a teaching post) and the inherent instability of short-term employment¹.

Finding a position was rarely a matter of public advertisement; instead, it relied heavily on a complex web of social credit². Tutors depended on "social credit relationships" such as kinship, lineage, master-disciple bonds, and geographical ties to secure a place in a household³. These intermediaries acted as guarantors for the tutor’s character and scholarly competence⁴. However, as the era progressed and competition intensified, the cost of securing these roles rose significantly, while their stability plummeted⁵.

This precarious existence led to a common life cycle of "finding a post, losing it, and seeking another"⁶. Such instability fundamentally altered the professional spirit of the tutor class⁷. Rather than a path for self-actualization or the lofty pursuit of "the Way," teaching became a survival strategy—a means to "support one's studies through teaching"⁸. This shift contributed to the perceived decline of "the Way of the Teacher" (shidao) during the Late Ming, as the tutor became a wandering laborer of the intellect rather than a permanent fixture of moral authority⁹. Ultimately, unlike other emerging professional groups of the time, private tutors failed to form a cohesive professional identity, remaining fragmented by their constant struggle for economic security¹⁰.