Breaking the Cycle of Planned Obsolescence: A Theory of Constraints Approach to Sustainable Consumerism
Abstract
Since the 1950s, engineered obsolescence—the deliberate shortening of product life to drive repeat purchases—has been a structural feature of consumer capitalism. While it supports economic growth, it also fosters waste, environmental damage, and consumer distrust. Using the Evaporating Cloud (Conflict Resolution Diagram) and the Five Focusing Steps, this paper explores how the Theory of Constraints can help reconcile the conflict between profit-driven consumerism and sustainability with integrity.
1. The Core Conflict (Evaporating Cloud)
| Element | Description |
|---|---|
| Goal (A) | Build a prosperous and sustainable economy. |
| Need B | Ensure business profitability and growth. |
| Need C | Ensure long-term environmental and social sustainability. |
| Action D | Encourage frequent product replacement and consumption. |
| Action D’ | Design durable, repairable, and sustainable products. |
| Conflict | D satisfies B but undermines C; D’ satisfies C but undermines B. |
2. Underlying Assumptions
Profitability depends on continuous sales, not lasting value.
Consumers will only buy if products fail or become obsolete.
Sustainable production cannot be profitable.
By challenging these assumptions, TOC helps evaporate the conflict.
3. Breaking the Constraint
The real system constraint in modern consumerism is the business model that links revenue to volume of new product sales.
This constraint forces both producers and consumers into a cycle of waste.
4. Exploiting and Elevating the Constraint
Exploit: Use TOC thinking to maximize profitability within the constraint by improving efficiency, modular design, or subscription-based upgrades.
Elevate: Transform the constraint by shifting the business model—from product sales to service-based, circular economy models, e.g.:
“Product as a Service” (e.g., leasing, repair credits)
Lifetime upgrade programs
Reuse, refurbish, and remanufacture systems
This maintains profitability (B) while also achieving sustainability (C).
5. Subordinate and Repeat
Regulations, consumer education, and marketing should all subordinate to this new model—aligning incentives toward durability, transparency, and ethical design.
As sustainability becomes the new norm, the next constraint (e.g., supply chain resilience, resource scarcity) will emerge for further improvement.
Summary
Planned obsolescence reflects a structural constraint—an outdated linkage between profit and consumption volume.
TOC enables a systemic transition to models that maintain business viability while promoting environmental and social integrity.
發表文章
