The Scapegoat’s Exit: Why Politicians Always Prefer a Corpse Over Accountability
There is an ancient, comforting ritual in the dark arts of governance: whenever a regime steers a ship straight into an iceberg, the captain does not apologize, resign, or adjust the course. Instead, he simply searches the deck for the most pliable bureaucrat in sight, hands him a pair of concrete boots, and tosses him overboard to appease the mutinous crowd.
We watched this timeless farce play out in Hong Kong when veteran broadcaster Leung Ka-wing was forced out following a damning government report accusing him of "management failures" at RTHK. As commentator Michael Chugani rightly pointed out, blaming Leung for the station's editorial spine or the city's political unraveling was a masterclass in institutional cowardice. The real architect of Hong Kong's slow-motion civic burial wasn't the head of a public broadcaster trying to keep the lights on; it was Carrie Lam and her masters in Beijing, systematically dismantling the city’s institutions brick by brick while demanding applause for their demolition work.
From an evolutionary standpoint, political self-preservation is a breathtakingly simple reflex. When a primate hierarchy is collapsing under the weight of its own incompetence, the dominant alpha never accepts the blame. To admit error is to invite a challenge to your status. Therefore, the system invents a scapegoat. You produce a heavily redacted report, pin the collective failures of an entire regime onto one retiring civil servant, and call it "accountability."
History is overflowing with these pathetic theatricals. Roman emperors blamed Christians for fires they likely started; dynastic mandarins executed loyal generals for losing battles dictated by court eunuchs. It is always the same comforting illusion: if we chop off enough heads of middle-management scapegoats, the structural rot at the top will magically vanish.
Carrie Lam walked away with her pension and her delusions of duty intact, leaving others to carry the cross for her historic wreckage. It is a cynical reminder that in the grand theater of state power, justice is never about truth; it is merely about finding someone small enough to fit inside the coffin.
accountability, political scapegoats, hong kong history, rthk, michael chugani, carrie lam, institutional decay, human nature, political cynicism, governance failure, evolutionary psychology, state power
代罪羔羊的下場:為什麼當權者永遠不會承認自己是災難本身
權力有一套歷久彌新的古老把戲:當一艘船在掌舵者的狂妄中直撞冰山、眼看就要沉沒時,船長從不打算穿上救生衣謝罪。他只會冷靜地在甲板上巡視一圈,挑選一個最溫馴、最方便推卸責任的公務員,一腳踹進海裡,好向群情激憤的乘客們交代。
看著香港資深新聞工作者梁家榮在官方炮製的「管理缺失」報告後黯然離職,你不得不讚嘆這種政治卸責的精準度。正如時事評論員褚簡寧所言,把香港整場政治自由的夭折怪罪在一個公營廣播機構的頭上,簡直是一場荒謬絕倫的黑色幽默。真正的操盤手、把这座城市亲手埋葬的人,正高高坐在特首辦公室裡享受著掌聲,而那些真正試圖在夾縫中維持一絲專業尊嚴的人,卻成了權力祭壇上隨時可以宰殺的犧牲品。
從生物演化的深層邏輯來看,這其實是靈長類動物最本能的防禦機制。當一個階級體系面臨崩潰、權威受到挑戰時,居於統治地位的alpha雄性絕不會承認自己無能。因為承認錯誤意味著交出權力。於是,造假、甩鍋、找代罪羔羊,就成了維護統治合法性的標準作業程序。寫一份洋洋灑灑的調查報告,把整個體制的爛帳全推給一個準備退休的局外人,然後冠冕堂皇地稱這叫「追究責任」。
歷史從不缺少這種令人齒冷的畫面。羅馬帝國縱火時嫁禍給基督徒,官僚體系出事時拿基層當替死鬼。人類似乎有一種根深蒂固的惰性:只要砍下夠多無辜者的頭顱,我們就能假裝高牆沒有倒塌,大廈依舊安全。
當林鄭月娥拍拍屁股帶著退休福利揚長而去時,留給香港的卻是一片被權力親手掏空的廢墟。這就是政治最殘酷的真相:在權力的棋盤裡,從來沒有什麼公正與真相可言,只有永遠在當砲灰的愚者,和那些永遠不用負責的贏家。
代罪羔羊, 政治卸責, 香港歷史, 褚簡寧, 官僚腐敗, 體制崩壞, 人性幽暗, 權力遊戲, 黑色幽默, 歷史反思, 政治諷刺,社會觀察