The Colonial Pecking Order: Why Oppressed Tribes Love to Look Down on Each Other
Taiwan and South Korea share an uncanny historical script. Both endured Japanese colonial rule, forced themselves through brutal authoritarian modernization, clawed their way to democracy, and remain politically fractured to this day.Yet, despite these striking parallels, mutual understanding has always been shockingly thin. Historical research into colonial-era Korean newspapers like The Chosun Ilbo reveals that when Koreans looked at Taiwan, they didn't see comrades in shared suffering. Instead, through the lens of their imperial masters, they saw an exotic, distant curiosity—a tropical island of headhunters, palm trees, and economic competitors for rice.
Why do populations under the same boot fail to empathize? Because human tribal psychology is ruthlessly status-driven.When primates are trapped beneath an apex predator—in this case, an imperial power—they cannot fight upward. Their cognitive bandwidth becomes consumed by survival and displacement. Since they cannot bite the alpha, they look sideways or downward to soothe their wounded ego. Adopting the colonizer’s gaze and feeling a flicker of superiority over another colonized group provides a cheap, chemical shot of dignity. It is a pathetic evolutionary defense mechanism:We may be slaves, but at least we aren't those wild people down south.
History teaches us a cynical lesson: shared misery does not automatically breed solidarity. It breeds a petty, fragmented hierarchy of the oppressed. Even today, mutual ignorance between neighboring democratic societies persists because the human brain is hardwired to care only about immediate turf and power dynamics, happily swallowing whatever caricature the ruling authorities feed them.
Taiwan history, Korea-Taiwan relations, colonial history, human nature, tribal psychology, evolutionary anthropology,East Asian politics, imperial gaze, social hierarchy, historical cynicism, cultural blindness, authoritarian modernization
被殖民者的階級迷思:為什麼受害者總愛俯視另一個受害者?
臺灣與韓國,歷史軌跡驚人地相似:同樣捱過日本殖民,同樣在威權下拼出血汗經濟,同樣磕磕絆絆地走向民主。然而,若翻開日治時期的朝鮮報紙,我們會驚訝地發現,當時的朝鮮人對臺灣的想像,充滿了獵奇、冷漠,甚至是一種微妙的優越感。在帝國的眼光下,臺灣被視為充滿瘴癘之氣的南方島嶼、長滿頭顱的蠻荒之地,或者僅僅是搶奪米價的經濟競爭者。
在殖民體制的鐵蹄下,按理說同病相憐的兩群人應該惺惺相惜。但人類的基因從來不是按「受害者同盟」來運作的。當靈長類被強大的壓迫者死死踩在腳下時,既然打不過頂頭上司,心裏那股窩囊氣該往哪裏發?答案是:向下看,或者向遠處看。
朝鮮人透過日本殖民者的濾鏡看臺灣,不把對方當成抵抗帝國的戰友,而是當成茶餘飯後的異國奇觀。這種心態,說穿了就是被殖民者的悲哀防衛機制——踩着另一個邊緣人,好讓自己覺得離權力的核心好像近了一寸。
歷史的荒謬之處正在於此:苦難從來不會自動昇華成人類的同理心。直到今天,這種地理上的疏離與文化上的盲點依然存在。人類始終是一隻目光短淺、只盯着自己地盤的地域動物。我們嘲笑過去的偏見,卻忘了自己今天面對其他受傷的群體時,心裏那一套冷漠的優越感,其實從來沒有變過。
臺灣歷史, 臺韓關係, 殖民歷史, 人性本能, 部落心理, 演化人類學, 東亞政治, 帝國凝視, 社會階級, 歷史諷刺, 文化盲點, 威權現代化